Which to book
Concert or daytime visit?
Evening performance or a daytime visit to St John's Co-Cathedral: what each gives you, what each leaves out, and when the after-hours tour is the better pick.
Book the Caravaggio performance ↗Quick answer
They are different tickets for different things. The daytime visit is a self-paced look at the whole cathedral and its museum. The evening is a short staged performance in the Oratory, in front of Caravaggio's painting, with half an hour in the cathedral first. Choose the day for breadth and the evening for the painting told aloud. Many travellers do both, and an after-hours guided tour adds front-row seats.
The short answer
Book the evening if the painting is your reason for going and you like a story told aloud. Book a daytime visit if you want the whole building at your own pace, with the museum and an audio guide. The two do not overlap much in what they give you, which is why they are not really rivals. The evening centres on one room and one canvas. The day spreads across the nave, the chapels and the collections. This guide sets them side by side.
What a daytime visit is
Wikipedia says visitors pay a fee, that the visitors' entrance is on Republic Street and that the museum next door holds art objects. Malta Uncovered adds that audio guides come with the entrance fee and that the cathedral is closed to sightseeing during Mass. A daytime visit is self-paced and covers the nave, the side chapels and the floor of knights' tombstones, with the museum alongside. Opening days and hours are on the cathedral's own website, and they change, so check there before you plan around them. Malta Uncovered adds that the main church entrance is on St John Street but the visitors' entrance is on the main street, opposite the law courts.
Read next: The cathedral and its Oratory
What the evening is
The evening is a performance of about 40 to 45 minutes in the Oratory, held after the daytime crowds, with the cathedral open to view without a guide for 30 minutes beforehand. The booking page lists the performance and that half hour, and does not list the museum or an audio guide. The producer's own page describes small audiences and rooms where nobody is far from the performers. The ticket is for the show, and the cathedral time is the lead-in to it.
What you see in each
The Oratory holds Caravaggio's The Beheading of Saint John the Baptist, and the booking page lists the viewing of the painting among the evening's highlights. A daytime visit takes in the Oratory too, alongside the nave decorated by Mattia Preti, the chapels of the Order's national groups and the marble tombstones of knights. Wikipedia describes the interior as one of the finest examples of high Baroque architecture in Europe. The evening gives you the painting in context. The day gives you the building around it. Wikipedia says the Oratory also holds Saint Jerome Writing, so the room holds two Caravaggio paintings.
Read next: The Beheading, explained
Pace, crowds and atmosphere
In the daytime you set the pace and linger where you like, in a building that Wikipedia calls one of Malta's most popular tourist attractions. The after-hours tour option is described on its booking page as a way to see the cathedral without the daytime hustle. The evening performance has a fixed shape and a seat, which suits people who like to be led through an hour and not choose their own route. Neither is better. They suit different moods. Classical audiences keep quiet while the music plays, which gives the evening a hush that a busy daytime nave cannot have.
Language and information
Malta Uncovered says the audio guide at the daytime visit is available in several languages, including English. The evening performance and the guided-tour option are both in English only, according to the booking pages. If English is not your first language and you like to listen at your own speed, the daytime audio guide may serve you better. If you follow English comfortably, the evening adds spoken stories that no wall label carries, and the music carries much of the mood. Check the audio guide's languages when you buy a daytime ticket.
The third option: after-hours tour with front-row seats
A separate booking page sells an after-hours guided tour of St John's Co-Cathedral in English, led by a professional guide, followed by front-row seats at the same performance. It lasts 1.5 hours, according to its page, and the same free cancellation applies. This is the option for travellers who want a guide's commentary on the building and a close seat for the music. It is a different listing from the performance alone, so read its page before you choose, since its contents and price differ.
Doing both
Nothing stops you booking a daytime visit and an evening on the same trip, and they complement each other. See the nave, chapels and museum by day, then return in the evening for the Oratory performance and the half hour of quiet viewing. The daytime ticket is separate and is not covered by the evening booking. A short rest between them helps, since both involve standing and walking on stone floors. No prices are quoted here, because both booking pages show live figures. If you do both, take the daytime visit first, so that the evening's stories land on a building you already know.
Who should pick which
Pick the evening if Caravaggio's painting is the point, if you like live music in a historic room, or if you have only a short time. Pick the daytime visit if you want the whole cathedral, the museum or an audio guide in your own language. Pick the after-hours tour if you want a guide and a front-row seat in one booking. If you cannot decide, the evening is the one that is hardest to replace, because a performance in that room is not something the day offers at all. Families with young children may prefer the daytime visit's freedom to move around, since the evening asks for quiet and a seat.
Who this isn't for
Neither option is a long classical concert, and neither lets you photograph the painting, since the booking page bars photography inside. If you want a full programme of music, a Valletta recital hall is the place to look, not this ticket. If you want a deep art-history course, the evening is a story told for a general audience, not a lecture, and a daytime visit with an audio guide, a book or a specialist guide will go further. If you are weighing the cost, remember that the booking pages show the live figures and that this guide does not quote prices.
Booking
Open the booking page for the evening, choose a date and note the start time beside it. Your confirmation repeats the time and names the door to use. Cancellation is free until the day before, and payment can wait. For the daytime visit, use the cathedral's own site for opening days and hours, since they change. For the after-hours tour, use its own booking page, linked from the booking section of this site. If an evening is full, the calendar will show it, and the performance does not run every night.
Frequently asked questions
Is the evening concert better than a daytime visit?
Neither is better. The evening is a short staged performance in front of the Caravaggio. The daytime visit covers the whole cathedral and museum at your own pace. Many travellers do both.
Does the evening ticket include the museum?
No. The booking page lists the performance and 30 minutes to view the cathedral, and does not list the museum or an audio guide.
Is a guide included in the evening?
No. The cathedral can be viewed without a guide for 30 minutes before. A separate after-hours tour adds a professional guide and front-row seats.
Which has more languages?
The daytime audio guide comes in several languages. The evening performance and the after-hours tour are in English only.
Can I do both on one trip?
Yes. The daytime visit is a separate ticket, so book each on its own page and choose dates that suit you.
Which is best for a short stay?
The evening, if the Caravaggio is your priority, because it fits in under two hours with the half hour beforehand. A daytime visit takes as long as you choose.
Sources